ussf

While researching a Permaculture Cooperative [blog] [video] in the summer of 2009 we visited Mondragon Cooperative [video] [photos] [blog] and enjoyed a day-tour of the cooperative, which included a factory tour and a lunch, history and business workshop. This video presentation includes an oral history from the days of the founder Don José María Arizmendiarrieta as the oldest farmers son and revolutionary journalist to the modern cooperative. Photos of the cooperative headquarters, the historical museum and the town of Arrasate.

Photo Credits: Kirstie Stramler and Nicholas Roberts

Mondragon boardroom

The oral history if given by Mikel Lezamiz who is the educational director of the Mondragon Cooperatives Corporation, the world’s largest consortium of worker-owned businesses located in the Basque Country of Northern Spain. Lezamiz is one of the most knowledgeable sources on the history and current operations of Mondragon’s 120 worker-owned businesses.

We went to Mondragon to research a Permaculture Cooperative: a global network of sustainability worker cooperatives. The Mondragon Permaculture.TV collection

YouTube Preview Image YouTube Preview Image YouTube Preview Image

To jumpstart US job market, turn workers into owners
Many Americans build wealth through their home. Why not through work?

In hard times like these, the co-op model makes sense. After all, public confidence in corporations, banks, and the larger financial system is at low ebb, while unemployment is at its highest level in 25 years. Homeownership, historically a reliable way to build equity, has been rocked by foreclosures. People are looking for other ways to do business and save money.

Many people think of co-ops as the hippie-dippy grocery store that sells organic goods. In fact, a 2009 study by the University of Wisconsin Center for Cooperatives found more than 29,000 cooperatives in the US, which make $500 billion in annual revenue, support 83,000 people, and pay $25 billion in wages and benefits. They include national firms such as credit unions, and local businesses such as the Alvarado Street Bakery in Petaluma, Calif., or the Evergreen Cooperative Laundry in Cleveland.

Source: Christian Science Monitor

Bringing Mondragon to America
by Chris Lindstrom on September 09, 2009

These core principles help provide the cooperative members with basic guidelines for working together in a cooperative environment, to commit themselves to personal development, teamwork, participatory management, joint projects, social entrepreneurialism, and finally, corporate excellence. The role of the Management Model is not just to make managers responsible for the success of their cooperative, but how to get workers to take on this responsibility and enthusiasm as well. It is not my impression that they have achieved this 100%, but I think that for an industrial community, they have perhaps set the highest standard for honoring worker rights than any other place in the world. However, this remains only to exist within the Basque region and has not spread in any major way to the multitude of companies that have come under MMC ownership in the past couple years.

The MCC claims that they are being very mindful of the environment by doing things such as reducing their carbon emissions in all of their cooperatives. While, in certain areas they were undoubtedly far ahead of countries such as the US, they were not quite as active in areas of sustainable agriculture. Agricultural production as a commercial sector simply was not as much of a priority as residential goods or the retail of non local food products. So it can be safely said that the MCC is by no means perfect. However, it provides one of the most sophisticated institutional examples of a truly egalitarian and socially just economic system.

Source: Economics of Peace

Mondragón and the United Steelworkers/ New opportunity for the co-op and labor movements?
B Y E R B I N C R O W E L L

Here in the U.S., we have sewn many of the seeds of such a cooperative economy. For example, food co-ops have been partners in the success of worker co-ops Equal Exchange and Alvarado Street Bakery. Food co-ops and others have created loan funds, such as the Cooperative Fund of New England and Northcountry Cooperative Development Fund, that support cross-sector co-op development. We have worker co-ops that have integrated union representation, such as Collective Copies, and examples of multi-stakeholder co-ops, such as Weaver Street Market and FEDCO Co-op Seeds, that bring workers and consumers together within a single enterprise. We have international management training programs such as the St. Mary’s University Master of Management: Co-operatives and Credit Unions, and cross-sector organizations such as the National Cooperative Business Association. And we have a growing awareness that “co-operation among co-ops” is not just a principle but a key competitive advantage.

In this context, the agreement signed by Mondragón and the United Steelworkers is much more than a piece of paper. For unions, it’s a new opportunity to explore the human and economic potential of cooperative ownership, rather than settling for adversarial relationships with capitalist enterprises. For worker co-ops, this may be an opening to deepen solidarity with organized labor through new and innovative structures. And for the cooperative movement as a whole, we have an opportunity to reassess our assumptions about the role of workers, the meaning of membership, and the potential for engaging employees in nonadversarial settings characterized by shared ownership.

Multi-stakeholder co-ops, highlighted by Mondragón’s astonishing success, would seem to offer a promising area for exploration among co-ops in the U.S. These structures contribute a uniquely cooperative approach to labor relations that would strengthen our competitive advantage in an increasingly challenging global economy.

Source: Cooperative Grocer

YouTube Preview Image

Mondragon Permaculture with Bill Mollison

In the Mp3 audio of Bill Mollison 1983 PDC (Permaculture Designers Certificate) in Stanley,Tasmania (Geoff Lawton attended) that are available as DVD for sale and on the internet, Bill Mollison talks at length about the Mondragon Cooperative (along with Commonworks etc) as an organisational framework – a natural order of People Care and Fair Share for Earth Care that permaculture projects ought use.

I actually found and listened to these Mp3’s just before we went to Mondragon (such is life!). We really did Build The Road as We Travel (the only book on Mondragon that we saw on tour). Also, re-reading the Permaculture Designers Manual 1988 he has a couple of references again to Mondragon in the Alternative Nation section towards the end of the book.

Source: Permaculture.coop – Notes on Mondragon & Permaculture, GaiaPermaculture.com

Mondragon or Arrasate, the place in the Basque Country
Mondragon Cooperative

At the USSF2010 Mandela Marketplace‘s Quinton Sankofa and James Berk of Mandela Foods Cooperative presented to a workshop hosted by Permaculture.coop called Pathways to Sustainable Self-Governance. Other presenters included Gavin Raders of Planting Justice and Mike Leung of Worker Cooperative Credit Union.

Organised and facilitated by Kirstie Stramler, filmed by Patrick O’Conner for permaculture.coop


History of West Oakland and background for Mandela Marketplace & Mandela Foods Coop
YouTube Preview Image

Quinton Sankofa explains the history of West Oakland and the context for the Mandela Marketplace.

West Oakland Today and the context of Mandela Marketplace
YouTube Preview Image

James Berk and Quinton Sankofa describe West Oakland today and the context for the Mandela Foods Cooperative and Mandela Marketplace.

Challenges for Mandela Marketplace & Mandela Foods Coop
YouTube Preview Image

James Berk and Quinton Sankofa describe CHALLENGES of the Mandela Foods Cooperative and Mandela Marketplace.

Community-led and controlled development
YouTube Preview Image

Quinton Sankofa explains the Mandela Marketplace alternative for community-led or community controlled development

Successes
YouTube Preview Image

James Berk and Quinton Sankofa describe SUCCESSES of the Mandela Foods Cooperative and Mandela Marketplace.

Financing Worker Cooperatives
YouTube Preview Image

Quiton Sankofa describes some of the realities of financing worker cooperatives, Mike Leung of the pre-start Worker Cooperative Credit Union also describes the national situation and the exception Arizmendi Association of Coops

Abolish human rentals and fund worker-cooperatives says Mike Leung

YouTube Preview Image

Filmed at the USSF2010 event “Pathways to Sustainable Self-Governance” hosted by Permaculture.coop, organised by Kirstie Stramler and filmed by Patrick O’Conner

Source: Abolish Human Rentals, Worker-Cooperative Credit Union (pre-start-up)

New videos uploaded from Pathways to Sustainable Self Governance, the Detroit USSF2010 workshop organized by Permaculture TV.   Excerpt from workshop description:

This workshop outlines a vision for a democratic, worker-owned, advanced industrial ecology society. We seek pathways to provide the burgeoning food education/justice movement with the tools to become economically sustainable, and to link the emerging green industrial worker cooperatives with them into sovereign networks. Once active, such networks can become the basis for sustainable, socially just communities that revitalize locales via open source sustainable agriculture and manufacturing methods. Our panel — with academic, commercial, and school of hard knocks experience — will frame the demonstrated solutions, numerous pieces of the puzzle that we as a society need to put together.

Gavin Raders explains how, where, and to what effect Planting Justice implements their ecologically sound and socially just philosophy.   Videos below include a 30-second excerpt on the utility of city waste streams, followed by 6 sequential videos that comprise Gavin’s presentation at our USSF 2010 workshop.  Great stuff!

Espousing and embodying the Permaculture meme, “the problem is the solution”. Gavin Raders on the utility of city waste streams: http://www.vimeo.com/13797340  Video Credit:  Patrick O’Connor of Oakland Sol

Introduction. Planting Justice (guiding principles) combines grassroots organizing with Permaculture to simultaneously address the food, economic, ecological, knowledge, and non-profit crises: http://www.vimeo.com/13797422  Video Credit:  Patrick O’Connor of Oakland Sol

Permaculture, “just a word until it is put into practice”. In 1.5 years, Planting Justice has installed 60 permaculture gardens in homes, schools, affordable housing complexes, community centers, and at San Quentin Correctional Facility. Gavin encourages us to just get started, and advocates using their open-source resources, e.g. those available at http://plantingjustice.org/resources/sample-designs : http://www.vimeo.com/13797559  Video Credit:  Patrick O’Connor of Oakland Sol

Implementing the Permaculture meme, “stacking functions” in an economic sense. Gavin describes how Planting Justice (programs) enacts a Permaculture Business Model: http://www.vimeo.com/13797656  Video Credit:  Patrick O’Connor of Oakland Sol

Projects. Optimal locales for installations with maximum benefit are institutions such as churches and community centers, which have the dual advantages of already being social meeting places and of owning land.  Gavin describes how the learning process is often mutual, as Planting Justice (projects) facilitates installations at a local middle school, at San Quentin Prison, and at affordable housing complexes: http://www.vimeo.com/13797759  Video Credit:  Patrick O’Connor of Oakland Sol

Why City Permaculture?  Planting Justice embodies the Permaculture philosophy “the problem is the solution“.  Gavin Raders quotes Grace Lee Boggs “crises are opportunities“, and explains how advantageous cities waste streams can be when pollution is simply treated as mis-placed nutrients: http://www.vimeo.com/13797848  Video Credit:  Patrick O’Connor of Oakland Sol

Conclusion. Gavin Raders of Planting Justice encourages us to replicate their efforts, and to build sustainable and regenerative businesses off of the waste streams of cities.  Check their website for free educational workshops upcoming at their Oakland space: http://www.vimeo.com/13797924  Video Credit:  Patrick O’Connor of Oakland Sol

** Up next in this series: USSF 2010 videos of Quinton Sankofa and James Berk of Mandela Marketplace and Mandela Foods **

Industrial Symbiosis Kalundborg, Denmark
symbiosis

Pathways to Sustainable Self-Governance: Democratic Open-Source Food and Manufacturing Networks

Short Description

Worker Cooperative Networks for Sovereignty of Food, Commerce, & Community: Panel/Breakouts/Discussion to Envision & Chart Implementation Framework of Industrial Permaculture Ecology

Full Workshop Proposal

Pathways to Sustainable Self-Governance: Democratic Open-Source Food and Manufacturing Networks

Workshop Information
Event Date: Fri, 06/25/2010 – 3:30pm – 5:30pm
Event Location: Wayne County Community College: 23A

Full Description:

This workshop outlines a vision for a democratic, worker-owned, advanced industrial ecology society. We seek pathways to provide the burgeoning food education/justice movement with the tools to become economically sustainable, and to link the emerging green industrial worker cooperatives with them into sovereign networks. Once active, such networks can become the basis for sustainable, socially just communities that revitalize locales via open source sustainable agriculture and manufacturing methods. Our panel — with academic, commercial, and school of hard knocks experience — will frame the demonstrated solutions, numerous pieces of the puzzle that we as a society need to put together.

Pathways to Sustainable Self-Governance: Democratic Open-Source Food and Manufacturing Networks

Short Description

Worker Cooperative Networks for Sovereignty of Food, Commerce, & Community: Panel/Breakouts/Discussion to Envision & Chart Implementation Framework of Industrial Permaculture Ecology

Full Workshop Proposal

Pathways to Sustainable Self-Governance: Democratic Open-Source Food and Manufacturing Networks

Collaborating Organizations

Arizmendi Association of Cooperatives (2543) | Mandela Marketplace (2339) | Planting Justice (1407) | Mandela Foods Cooperative (2340) | Abolish Human Rentals (1460) | Permaculture Cooperative (1720)


Photo: Oakland Sol: Oakland Sustaining Ourselves Locally who generously provided accommodation, workspace and knowledge during incubation of this workshop

Collaborating Organizations

Arizmendi Association of Cooperatives (2543)

The Arizmendi Association of Cooperatives is itself a cooperative made up of five member businesses: four cooperative bakeries and a development and support collective. Members share a common mission, share ongoing accounting, legal, educational and other support services, and support the development of new member cooperatives by the Association. http://arizmendi.coop


Mandela Marketplace (2339)

Mandela Market Place is a pioneer in development, application and assessment of community food systems. The organization evolved since 2001, first as a project of the Environmental Justice Institute – Tides Center, until incorporating in 2005 as a stand-alone 501c3 organization with a goal to strengthen community health, integrity and indentity by providing economic opportunity and empowerment for inner-city Oakland residents and businesses, and local family farms. Mandela MarketPlace works directly with community residents, local, state and federal agencies, non-profits, small business owners, and farmers to support strategies to meet food needs, expand economic opportunity and increase self-reliance of low-income and disenfranchised people. http://mandelamarketplace.org


Planting Justice (1407)

Planting Justice is a non-profit organization based in Oakland, CA dedicated to food justice, economic justice, and sustainable local food systems. We are the first organization of our kind to combine ecological training and urban food production with a grassroots door-to-door organizing model that will vastly increase our educational community outreach, help us to recruit volunteers, decentralize our fundraising sources, and provide local jobs that also train young community organizers. http://www.plantingjustice.org


Mandela Foods Cooperative (2340)

Mandela Foods Cooperative is a locally-owned and operated full-service grocery store and nutrition education center located in West Oakland, a community long underserved in grocery retail. The present undersupply of food retail in West Oakland represents an opportunity to leverage untapped local buying power into new business and employment opportunities and healthy eating options for West Oakland residents. The Cooperative will offer local goods, wholesome, fresh and affordable foods grown on family farms, nutrition education classes and a cooperative economic investment program that provides multi-level investment for community residents. http://www.mandelafoods.com


Abolish Human Rentals (1460)

Abolish Human Rentals is dedicated to bringing an old idea into the public conscience, that the standard employment relationship, a contract for the rental of people, is invalid due to the inalienable rights of humans. It is based on the already widely held principle of the non-transferability of responsibility for one’s actions. That principle, taken to its logical conclusion, means the rental of humans have no more legitimacy than their sale. http://www.abolishhumanrentals.org


Collaborating Organizations:
Arizmendi Assn. of Cooperatives (2543) — http://arizmendi.coop — and
Mandela Marketplace (2339) — http://mandelamarketplace.org — and
Planting Justice (1407) — http://www.plantingjustice.org — and
Mandela Foods Cooperative (2340) — http://www.mandelafoods.com — and
Abolish Human Rentals (1460) — http://www.abolishhumanrentals.org

Language(s): English
Tracks:
Climate Justice: sustainability, resources and land
Democracy and Governance

Important pieces that will be presented here include the successful strategies employed in the worker cooperative networks/alliances of Mondragon, Ohio, and the San Francisco Bay Area, Permaculture design strategies implemented even in harsh climate zones, Denmark’s national industrial symbiosis program, non-parasitic capitalization of non-hierarchical enterprises, and regenerative urban food justice paradigms.

Participants will self-organize into groups to construct models that put some of the pieces together. Workshop participants will then seek to bolster viability of the proposed models, emphasizing possible pilot programs in Detroit, Oakland and in Brooklyn.

Panel members include Quinton Sankofa of Mandela Marketplace and James Berk of Mandela Foods Cooperative, Mike Leung of the embryonic Worker Cooperative Credit Union, and Gavin Raiders of Planting Justice. Facilitator: Kirstie Stramler of Permaculture Cooperative.

For updates leading up to USSF 2010, see the panel and workshop group pages on http://organize.ussf2010.org and videos on http://permaculture.tv/tag/ussf2010/ .

Organizer Name: Kirstie Stramler
Organizer Email: kirstie@permaculture.tv
First Sponsoring Organization Name: Permaculture Cooperative

An interview with Mike Leung, founder of pre-start-up Worker Cooperative Credit Union

Mike Leung

Mike Leung on Abolish Human Rentals on Worker Cooperatives from Permaculture Cooperative on Vimeo.

Worker Cooperative Credit Union

We are organizing a credit union that will serve worker cooperatives in the United States. This group is in the process of applying for a federal charter. We currently do not have an active charter and are not federally insured.

Worker cooperatives are businesses that are worker owned and democratically managed by their members. The credit union will help meet the following needs of worker cooperatives:

1) The worker co-op credit union will provide financial services for worker cooperatives and their members. Worker cooperatives often have difficulty attaining credit. This credit union will provide business lending exclusively to worker cooperatives. It will also provide personal loans for members’ capital contributions, as well as general consumer lending to its individual members. The credit union will provide a way for the members to support worker cooperatives through their use of its financial services.

2) The credit union will support technical assistance for its worker cooperative members. This may include financial, legal, or organizational assistance. It will also support efforts to develop new cooperatives and replicate existing ones.

3) The credit union will support education and awareness about worker cooperatives. It will help highlight the benefits of worker ownership and democratic management in the workplace.

Source: Worker Cooperative Credit Union

Mike Leung talks about Abolish Human Rentals and the Worker Cooperative Credit Union

Mike Leung on Abolish Human Rentals on Worker Cooperatives from Permaculture Cooperative on Vimeo.

Action

We are unfortunately in an environment where an uncompromising purist for the abolition of human rentals would be a pariah. While it is never pleasant to compromise one’s beliefs, in practice the vast majority accept some level of hypocrisy in their actions. Which compromises should be made, and at what cost, needs to be an active discussion among modern abolitionists. Those choices are a sign of a vibrant movement dealing with the realities of applying theory in practice. Theory for its own sake is pointless. It is only when theory becomes widely known and widely applicable that it can reach its full potential.

Time and resources are limited, so it is important to think strategically about the most efficient ways to have an impact. This does not mean everyone should reach the same conclusions. Circumstances differ, as do abilities, and energy. Embrace these differences as a sign of progress and diversity.

There are many steps that can be taken to abolish human rentals. By analogy one can think of appropriate actions if they were seeking to abolish slavery. I will list a few things that can be done here, some more practical, others less so:

Refuse to rent yourself – Demand a vote and demand profit appropriation. Suggest your business be converted to a worker cooperative. Or become self employed.

Boycott businesses that use rented humans – Refuse to support them through your consumption. This obviously isn’t so easy in today’s society, but shifting consumption to worker cooperatives when possible definitely helps.

Divest from business that use human rentals – Don’t finance them by investing in the stock market and don’t buy their bonds. Socially responsible alternatives do exist. For starters use credit unions instead of banks. While credit union workplaces aren’t democratically managed it is a small step in the right direction.

Support worker cooperatives – Purchase from your local worker cooperative, learn about what they are doing, how they operate, and how their members and community benefit.

Educate your friends, family, and coworkers – Spread awareness, start a discussion. Due to some heavy ideological baggage this is a difficult topic to discuss with strangers, without sounding crazy. Leverage existing relationships and connections.

Organize, protest, demonstrate – Demand the immediate and unconditional abolition of human rentals. Civil disobedience has historically been the most effective opposition to injustice. Business as usual means people’s rights can continue to be ignored.

There are impediments to taking action of any sort: personal inconvenience, cost, loss of social standing, and incarceration to name a few. To act in face these or more serious consequences requires courage and support. People typically draw the line when action might threaten their career, which they deem to have invested too much to risk. Besides, a job is rarely something people can sacrifice. That barrier is undoubtedly present here. Advocacy on this issue carries significant risk and the need for mutual support is essential. Efforts to provide support and build a viable alternative should not be neglected

Source: Abolish Human Rentals

Quinton Sankofa explains how Mandela Marketplace, West Oakland accepted the community call for ownership of problem and solutions

YouTube Preview Image

Sustainable Self-Governance – Fri 25th, 3.30-5.30 pm USSF2010 – Detroit – Wayne County Community College http://permaculture.coop/ussf2010

YouTube Preview Image

planting justice

mandela food, mandela marketplace
http://permaculture.coop/ussf2010

USSF Map, Detroit: points of interest for USSF participants. Main website = http://USSF2010.org Wiki website = http://USSFwiki.org

View USSF Map, Detroit in a larger map

Edits to the map which seem to conflict with a map of points of interest for USSF participants will be edited away. Contact Mark, markwdilley@gmail.com for more info or to get editing rights.

CC+ 2011 Permaculture TV free video cooperative By Permaculture Cooperative ~ government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the Earth Suffusion WordPress theme by Sayontan Sinha